China overshadows US attention to
tsunami zone
By Vishakha N. Desai
Christian Science Monitor, January 28, 2005
A US citizen born in India, I happened to be there when the tsunami
disaster struck, and saw firsthand how the generosity of the American response was received by South Asians. US media attention and
outpouring of American support was admirable; images of the US military
leading humanitarian relief efforts made me proud. But I also
encountered wariness about the level of genuine long-term US engagement and leadership in the region.
It was understood that American media stars would leave and America's
attention would waver as other stories, such as the approaching Iraqi
elections, dominate the news. Just when the real work of rebuilding
must begin, and the emotional devastation will manifest, America will
inevitably turn its gaze to the next thing.
Or will it? Can the US learn from this disaster to develop a longer
span of attention to life in Asia?
The need for sustained US engagement was apparent to Asians even before the Dec. 26 earthquake triggered the deadly wave. Just prior to the
tsunami, I traveled throughout Southeast Asia as the new president of
the Asia Society, a US-based international organization. Across the
region, from Thailand and Singapore to Indonesia and Malaysia, I heard
one thing loud and clear: Asian regionalism - trade and intra-Asian
political and cultural cross-currents - is expanding as never before,
while the US sits on the sidelines.
Distracted by terrorism and the Middle East, Washington seems content
to watch its influence in Asia decline while China fills the void. My
Asian colleagues reported this resignedly, yet not without some
yearning for a stronger US presence.
The $350 million US government commitment to tsunami relief and heroic
logistical efforts are historic, though not the world's largest, and
not enough by themselves to transform the emerging politics of the
region. Japan pledged $500 million, and other nations' per capita
contributions are much higher than the [$1.20] per American offered by
the US. China pledged $85 million in government aid (outbidding
Taiwan's $50 million) and dispatched large medical teams and other
help, for example working with Japan to rebuild tourism in ASEAN
(Association of Southeast Asian Nations) countries. Though compared
with Washington, Beijing cannot yet mount massive relief efforts far
from its shores; China's official aid, plus its unprecedented $45
million in private donations, illustrates its new and strategically
powerful commitment to engaging its neighbors.
Prime Minister Wen Jiabao personally flew to Jakarta to attend the
post-tsunami gathering of ASEAN (once hostile to China) and proposed an
international meeting in Beijing on a permanent tsunami warning system
that would look beyond the results of the United Nations meeting on
disaster preparedness in Kobe, Japan. Vice-Premier Hui Liangyu kicked
it off this week, saying "We should take cooperation in earthquake and
tsunami early warning as an opportunity and extend it to a wider range
of collaboration."
The China Daily editorialized that tsunami coverage "has surely
promoted a recognition throughout South and East Asia that China is a
good friend in time of need."
China is consciously showcasing itself in this role. It seems to
understand that beyond the dollar amount of its relief pledge, the true
test of regional leadership in 21st century Asia will be sustained,
proven engagement, demonstrated as much by ongoing interaction as by
the flow of aid.
Though not a relief organization, the Asia Society for the first time
in its 50-year history decided to raise and direct money to NGOs in
tsunami-stricken areas. But beyond immediate financial help or even
physical reconstruction, responding to the disaster's longer-term
cultural, political, spiritual, social, and economical impacts requires
more than sending money, vital as that is. It requires that American
government, media, and citizens learn about modern Asian life and
become personally engaged, sustaining and developing a stronger focus
and basis for empathy, long after the media spotlight wanes.
Let us hope that the shock of the tsunami will spark this commitment in
Americans: to follow and support ongoing efforts at rebuilding
sustainable lives for the hundreds of thousands affected, and in the
larger context, to recognize America's obligation to deepen its
understanding and engagement with the Asia Pacific region, where more
than half of the human race resides.
Vishakha N. Desai is president of the Asia Society. |